International Standards

Global Harmonization of Standards for the Care, Use and Ethical Oversight of Animals in Science


ICLAS is leading a new initiative to produce a document outlining high-level, globally harmonized performance (outcome-based) standards for the care, use and ethical oversight of animals in science that supports quality science and promotes animal well-being.

The target date for completing this work is early 2028.


Why is this initiative needed?

Legislation, guidelines and codes for research animal care, use and oversight exist in all regions, including several international documents. However, across the globe, there is great variation in the aspects covered, when they were produced and how well they are followed. Some of the main texts widely used as references are becoming outdated.

Differences in how experiments using animals are planned and conducted, how animals are housed and cared for, as well as personnel competence and research governance and oversight, are among the well-documented factors known to impact animal welfare, research reproducibility and robustness. Good standards that are effectively implemented are also important for meeting public expectations.


A single set of high-level performance standards, with truly international reach and acceptance, is a needed step toward improving welfare and science. Having a transparent set of expected standards endorsed and promoted by key organisations could:


  • Improve research quality and reproducibility.

  • Improve standards of animal welfare.

  • Allow a better understanding of standards in other regions.

  • Give increased confidence to the scientific community about studies in the scientific literature.

  • Improve the confidence of funding bodies and journal publishers in the scientific and ethical quality of work being carried out and submitted for publication.

  • Help inform and support the work of organisations operating across regions and multiple countries (e.g. pharmaceutical companies, animal breeders).

  • Assist accreditation organisations that use standards in this sector.

  • Improve the confidence of wider society in how animals are used and cared for in research.


Importantly, these standards should be viewed as guidance and not as substitutes for following relevant local and national legislative and regulatory requirements.

Who will have input into the creation of these standards?


ICLAS approached relevant representative global and regional bodies, including science councils and federations of laboratory animal science associations, to invite them to play a key role in guiding the development of these standards.


The following organisations are participating in this initiative:

  • AAALAC International (Global)

  • AALAS (USA)

  • AFLAS (Asia)

  • ANZCCART (Australasia)

  • CCAC (Canada)

  • CIOMS (Global)

  • FELASA (Europe)

  • FESSACAL (South America)

  • FESAHANCCAL (North America, Central America and the Caribbean)

  • IACLAM (Global)

  • PAN-LASE (Africa)


In addition, the following organisation has indicated that it will endorse the document produced:

  • International Science Council (Global)


We are pleased to see such wide-ranging support, covering every continent except Antarctica.

Drafting Committee and Working Group members represent and bring diverse perspectives from 34 nations. In selecting Working Group members, a balance needed to be struck between expertise and geographical representation, while for some Working Groups, expertise was the primary consideration.

Geographical representation meant having a country within a region represented, rather than membership of a specific organisation, as some contributing organisations are global and others regional. Given the need to balance expertise and geographical representation for most Working Groups, and to prioritise expertise for others, not every continent is represented in every Working Group.


How will this initiative be coordinated?

To facilitate the efficient management of the project (e.g. time, cost and communication) and the production of the draft standards, representative organisations with a global or regional (e.g. continental) representative role were more heavily involved in the initial activities.

The ICLAS Special Working Group on Global Harmonization (SWGGH) established a Drafting Committee made up of representatives from partnering organisations that had expressed their wish to participate in this initiative.

The Drafting Committee membership reflects geographical and disciplinary diversity. This committee recommended specialists and experts from their organisations and networks, who now form the Working Groups, each comprising 5 to 7 members.


The composition of the Working Groups received final approval from the ICLAS SWGGH.

Working Groups are responsible for producing the content for each section of the standards, which will then be reviewed and agreed upon by the Drafting Committee and finally approved by the ICLAS SWGGH.

A Project Coordinator with expertise in international projects has been appointed by ICLAS to help manage the delivery of this initiative.

There will be two rounds of consultation on the draft texts with the wider community.

To ensure that a broad range of perspectives and expertise is incorporated into the production of the standards, drafts will be shared widely with other relevant organisations, including national authorities and associations, as well as other interested groups such as representatives of scientific journal publishers and the pharmaceutical sector.

As part of this feedback process, input will also be sought, as appropriate, from specialty groups within laboratory animal science, including those working with specific animals (e.g. wildlife and non-human primates) and across different fields of research (e.g. pharmacology, physiology, neuroscience and toxicology).

ICLAS, mainly through the Special Working Group on Global Harmonization, will retain ultimate control over this project and provide final approval of the version of the standards to be published.

What will be covered in this document?

It is recognised that several useful reference texts already exist.

The CIOMS/ICLAS Guiding Principles for Biomedical Research Involving Animals (2012, 4 pages) provides high-level principles. Ten fundamental principles are also set out in the Basel Declaration.

More expansively, Chapter 7.8 of the WOAH Terrestrial Animal Health Code, which covers the use of animals in research and education (included since 2010, 11 pages), provides additional guidance on some of the relevant concepts involved.

Widely used texts such as the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals (8th edition, USA, 2011, 246 pages) and the European Convention for the Protection of Vertebrate Animals Used for Experimental and Other Scientific Purposes (ETS 123) (1986, 48 pages), together with its associated Appendix A (2006, 109 pages), are more comprehensive.

These documents also include performance standards and some detailed engineering standards on aspects of species-specific housing and care, such as cage or enclosure dimensions.

ICLAS is clear that any new guidance produced as part of this initiative must add value to what is already available.

It is not ICLAS's intention to prescribe specific details covering every possible aspect of research animal care and use, nor is the development of engineering standards intended.

Engineering standards already exist for several parameters, usually related to housing and care. Although these standards can be helpful, they may differ greatly across regions, their scientific basis is not always clear, and they can quickly become outdated as understanding of animal behaviour, welfare and needs evolves.

Instead, the focus of this initiative will be to establish shared understandings and expectations regarding outcome-based standards for key factors that impact animal health and well-being, as well as scientific integrity.


The Drafting Committee and SWGGH have agreed on the following 12 areas of focus, each with an assigned Working Group:

  1. Animal Welfare
  2. Behavioral Needs of Animals
  3. Veterinary Care
  4. Ethical Oversight
  5. Humane Endpoints
  6. Experimental Design
  7. Ethical Principles
  8. Training and Competency
  9. Culture of Care
  10. Sourcing of Animals
  11. End of Research Options
  12. Physical Infrastructure and Maintenance

There are, of course, challenges associated with standards based on performance outcomes. These can be subjective. For example, opinions may differ on whether animals' needs are being met or whether an ethical review process is robust and effective.

However, on balance, it is considered that the guidance produced as part of this initiative should focus on defining performance outcomes that support the conduct of high-quality science while ensuring that animals have a "good life", in line with the Five Domains approach to evaluating animal welfare.


What will the final standards look like?

As an approximate guide, it is envisaged that the standards document produced through this initiative will be around 40–50 pages long, allowing approximately 4–5 pages per topic.

The standards will not seek to provide an exhaustive account of everything that could be said on each topic. Instead, they will aim to communicate clearly and concisely shared understandings of the most important aspects, including why specific practices are necessary and what they should achieve in practice.

The vision is that the final published standards will be valuable to the global scientific community and the wider community, including regulators and other stakeholders involved in the use of animals in research and testing.

The aim is to establish expectations and a shared understanding of the key factors and actions that support high-quality, ethical science and good animal welfare.

These standards should be viewed as guidance and not as substitutes for compliance with relevant local and national legislative and regulatory requirements.

It is also recognised that institutions and countries will vary in their current ability to meet some or all of the elements outlined in the standards.

While the high-level performance (outcome-based) standards will be designed to be operational and realistically achievable, they will also serve to encourage continuous improvement. Examples of leading practices to aspire to will also be included.


Contact Information

For questions about this initiative, please contact:

ICLAS Special Working Group on Global Harmonization

Email: globalharmonisation@iclas.org


Five Domains https://www.mdpi.com/2076-2615/10/10/1870

ILAR Guide https://www.mdpi.com/2076-2615/10/10/1870

ETS123 and Appendix A https://norecopa.no/media/2iydns5h/ets-123-original.pdf

https://felasa.eu/Portals/0/Library/Cons123(2006)_AppendixA_en.pdf?ver=RoWmQzq5GoZpVwU3K9jw_g%3D%3D 

WOAH terrestrial animal code https://www.woah.org/en/what-we-do/standards/codes-and-manuals/

Basel Declaration https://animalresearchtomorrow.org/en/basel-declaration

 



Become a Iclas Member